Jeni's Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks Ice Cream - 16oz

I discovered this Jeni's flavor way too late, it instantly became my favorite. Target puts it on sale pretty often, and I stock up whenever I have the room in my freezer. Delicious

This icecream is perfect. I used to like the High Five Candy Bar from Jeni's, but ultimately found the caramel overwhelming and sickeningly sweet, and biting down wrong on the pretzels made me feel like I'd break a tooth. But this icecream removes all that and keeps everything essential. It's really just simple and delicious, salted peanut butter icecream and deliciously thin and crispy dark chocolate flakes. The ingredients are pretty clean, nothing too scary going on in this icecream, and maybe that's part of the price. Because this IS pricey. There are 48 oz containers of chocolate peanut butter icecream for half the price. This is definitely a premium icecream, I feel like even reducing the price by $1 would make it more accessible, but honestly when they have suckers like me addicted to it, the price is more likely to go UP $1... Oh, almost forgot. Pair this with a fruit icecream, I use Ben & Jerry's strawberry cheesecake. SO GOOD. Perfect combination. Seriously try it.

This ice cream is AMAZING!!! I say this as someone who isn’t an extreme peanut butter fan. This is the best peanut butter anything I’ve ever tasted. The chocolate flecks and salt add a lovely dimension without taking away from the peanut butter. The chocolate is just a touch - it’s perfect!

My FAVORITE Jeni’s ice cream! It’s so good and the perfect amount of sweetness! The saltiness and chocolate go perfect together! Worth every penny!

It’s the perfect combo of salty and sweet. I absolutely LOVE that it’s GF and celiac safe! The chocolate flecks are delicious. Some would argue it’s too sweet and I definitely eat it in moderation, but it is absolutely delicious. The only downside is it runs on the pricier end for a small pint. If you love chocolate and peanut butter, it’s a must try.

The salty peanut butter ice cream with the dark chocolate flecks go together perfectly! If you think the chocolate will melt, it won’t. It’s a very dark chocolate but it isn’t bitter. The ice cream base is the star though. It has that nice salt like a Reeses does but isn’t as cloyingly sweet. Definitely a favorite of mine!

Only worth buying when on sale or for a special treat. Otherwise, the price is not worth it for the quantity

Haven’t figured out the appeal of Jeni’s ice cream yet. I do appreciate that they have decent ingredients but the flavors are just ok. We have tried just about every flavor the stores carry, and a couple of them we haven’t even finished/thrown away. They could cut back on the sugar by about 10-15% too. Some are super sweet. Just not sold on this brand. This PB flavor in particular has been my least favorite. Additionally the chocolate pieces get stuck in your teeth and doesn’t melt to notice any flavor.

We served brownies and ice cream at a recent party. Of the 6 varieties of ice cream, this was the preferred one. Everyone loved it, and one scoop is extremely satisfying!

The first spoon tastes like heaven, it’s salty, sweet, peanut buttery, and crunchy from the chocolate bits. And it’s really good over all but it gets too overwhelming the more you eat.