Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Oiled Leather Plain Toe Casual Shoe

These shoes are some of the most comfortable shoes I own. I wear them with suits, and they are more comfortable than most “dress” shoes.

This is one of my favorite pairs of shoes. I enjoy their comfort and true to size fit. Would make for a great gift for any holidays or birthdays coming up.

These look really nice and are comfy, but they are squeaky.

I bought these 5 months ago and they were awesome. Love the look and they are extremely comfortable. However, after about 3 weeks of wear they developed a squeak or rather a creak. After about another month or two of wear i figured out the creak is coming from somewhere between the sole of the shoe and midsole (under the insole insert). I thought maybe this would wear out of them but that hasn't been the case, it has only grown from a nuisance to a flat out annoyance to to point of not being able to wear the shoes at all.

Insanely comfortable, great looking, impeccable quality.

this is my favorite pair of shoes I have ever owned.

My left shoe starts the day squeaking then gets quiet around mid afternoon. But the right shoe starts squeaking. It’s coming from the insole below my arch. Very frustrating bc the shoe is super comfortable. I just don’t like announcing myself all day long

I like the shoe, the way it looks, the comfort and the fit. However, after only a week or normal office wear, the stitching is coming unglued around the sole.

Shoes look nice but a couple considerations. #1) The sole inserts have a plastic/rubber bottom that rubs against the bottom of the shoe with same type of material.... so it squeaks a bit when walking. #2) yes, they are water proof but they have the comfort and feel of a rubber boot.

They fit my wide feet well and are very comfortable. But there is a squeak (that I can feel) in the midfoot insole that is difficult to get rid of. I feel like there should be a forum or something since I see this issue on a lot of j&m shoes

Nice looking shoe but the squeak horribly on any floor other than carpet. Embarrassing.

Within 2-3 months of infrequent use, the shoe's insole flattened. There is no longer expected support or padding

Noticed the McGuffey Plain Toe when looking for a new black/gray shoe to wear to work and the gray option was discontinued. I need something business casual that can be worn with chinos or jeans and not look out of place. I also wanted a shoe that looks good, is well made, and fits my wide toe box. The leather was a bit stiff at first but loosened up by the end of the first day wearing them. The shoe looks great, feels great, and my hope is that it turns out to be a good deal with build quality. I work for a non profit so I can't afford to buy new J&M shoes every year or so.

I walked all over Europe in these shoes. Miles and miles very comfortable ! surprisingly so....

Great shoes that look awesome both casually and dressy.

Great looking shoe that fits perfect! I love them!

Wear these for walking and work, and they look great! The bill of the shoe feels a bit narrow but I'm working it in. Can be used as dress shoes or a combination of casual and date night. I would recommend these shoes.

I love that these shoes look good and they're comfortable. They're wide enough that they don't pinch or rub on my feet. But the trim of the shoes around the ball of my foot (where they crease when I walk) started peeling away pretty early on, and every step I take they squeak. Very annoying.

This is my second pair, with the first pair lasting me for several years. I purchased a new pair about 6 months ago and within a few weeks (even with keeping shoe trees in after each time that I wore them), the sides began to separate. The price went up, but the quality went down.

This was my second pair of these shoes, the first pair lasted me a long time which is why I decided to buy them again. Unfortunately they either changed vendors of their quality control is lacking. This latest pair is separating from the leather to the sole, seams the stitching is inferior or not adequate. Very disappointing as I was hoping these shoes would last as long as the previous pair.