L'Oreal Paris Infallible Super Slim Liner 400 Black .034 fl oz

I have been using this eyeliner for years always got compliments and just recently, The last month or two. Each one I’ve purchased seems to dry out right after using once. I’ve purchased from several different stores hoping it. Was just a bad batch and still dry applicator. What’s going on??

I like the ink pen eye liner, however it smears and smudges! It doesn't even stay on in one place for long. I will not buy this again.

It just smells real bad. I bought it a couple of months ago and packaging and everything else is superb. But the eye liner smells chemically bad.

Flowerchild52 got it right! The "new" super slim is so dry it will not even line one eye. I, too, bought several thinking I must have gotten old stock. I used / loved this product for years - please bring it back!!!

For about the first week, this was a good eyeliner. After that it started to dry out which also led to the stick breaking. Now it's basically no color pay off and scratches the eyelid. I used less than half the product before giving up and throwing it out.

I have loved Loreal Super Slim eyeliner for years and years. But I am sad to have to give my all time favorite eyeliner a bad review. My favorite eyeliner has changed in the last six months. I can not even line one eye before it stops. It seems to be the eyeliner itself, or maybe the slim applicator. I did not want to give up my wonderful eyeliner, so I kept buying new ones thinking it maybe had been stored too long. After buying about 6 of them from different stores, I have had to give up on my wonderful Loreal Super Slim eyeliner. It breaks my heart. I just wanted to let you know in case it is a manufacturing change. I know I can't possibly be the only customer experiencing this problem. PLEASE bring back the Loreal Super Slim eyeliner that we have always known and loved!!!!

I just bought this, it sucks. Absolutely horrible, completely disappointed. It’s dry, the brush gets ruined with the littlest pressure. I got the shade ‘Black/noir’, it comes out a dark grey. Completely disappointed, e.l.f. Or Revlon is a better choice.

This product was my absolute favorite eyeliner for years. Just bought my first one since 2-3 years ago and it dried out in one use. L’oréal I don’t know what you did but PLEASE change the formula back.

Been using this for years!!!! Love this super slim eye liner ❤️

Smudges and transfers to my eyelid and lower lash line. Also dried after a couple uses

Whatever “improvement” they did to this sucks! Dries out quickly.

This used to be my favorite eyeliner, I have never bought a different kind in the last 10 years!! But as of this year, it seems that the formula has changed? The tip of the felt no longer has enough liquid and when you try to go over the line, it ends up erasing and smudging what you had. The tip gets blotchy and dries up and it is now impossible to make a sharp thin line. I thought that it was just a bad batch, but I have been purchasing these from different places and they are all this way now. I am so upset. Why did they change what used to be so good? 😭

This was such a disappointment! The bottom is juicy but the tip is dry so you end up trying to go back over the edges and end up making a mess of what would have been sharp lines. It also smudges everywhere! I have oily lids so I tried the liner over an eyeshadow primer but it didn’t help at all!

Not pigmented and the wand is flimsy so super hard to get a line

This liner immediately dried out. Not sure where the liquid went, or if there ever was any? Do better, L’Oreal. I like many of your products, but this is a total fail!

I bought this product in black. Seems to be dry and drags not like my previous versions.

I’ve been using this pen for years but the last 3 I have bought have been instantly dried out after the first swipe works great on my hand but for some reason won’t work on my eyelids anymore no matter what I try. Seriously bummed out this was always my go to :(

Please do not ever discontinue infallible super slim liquid eyeliner. It stays on so nicely...but most importantly, the user can create a thin, natural looking line which is not overbearing as some ladies do. I have loved this product for years and I cannot live without it!

This EYELINER is the worst of its kind!, I couldn't even get ink to come on to my eye I tried over & over finally had to wet the tip!!! It doesn't even last 12 hours as it says it does!! False advertising!!

the marker tip is juicier and more precise than any eyeliner pen i’ve used before (granted, i’ve only ever used drugstore makeup brands). However, this product does not work for extended wear, and if your skin is even slightly on the oily side, this product will not work for you. it smudges and wipes away far too easily. please consider coming out with a smudgeproof, waterproof version of this same eyeliner!!