Neutral Baking Cups - 150ct - Favorite Day™

Cups are too short, too thin, poor quality, and two different recipes stuck to the paper and wouldn’t release. Such a simple product, how can you screw it up? Sigh.

These suck. Used them with my tried and true recipes and these were the first baking cups to disintegrate like thin wet tissue. Yum. Target, stop getting cheap with all your stuff and just make better products that cost a wee bit more. We're willing to pay to not eat the dang paper.

Stuck to my food, become like soggy paper

Cute colors! Lots of options and worked well for our fall potluck.

Too small and they do not peel off! I resorted to cutting them off. Totally ruined my muffins.

Sticks to cupcakes. They are just paper. They smell and feel like the paper you would use in a printer.

Sticks to cupcakes and they are a lot smaller than other standard size liners. Tossing them.

Sticks to muffin horribly even when sprayed

Bought for cupcakes. I have a bazillion wrappers already (bakery) but I needed to match 3x100 and at most I had 80 of a single design. Honestly if I saw the reviews first, I wouldn’t have bought these! But I didn’t… I read them after they were in my home and before I started baking. I decided to test on 4 cupcakes to see if the negative reviews reflected my experience. They did not. My cupcakes stayed securely, not misshaped, not sticking, not peeling. They worked exactly like every other paper liner I had, perfectly. Granted yes, these are thinner than most but didn’t affect anything in the least IME. Not to mention the great value! I also didn’t experience much of the weird smells others noted. A slight bit when I first opened them but that’s like literally any packaged product likely due to the plastic being airtight directly after manufacturing. The next day, nothing at all and it didn’t have any effect on my cupcakes. And as hubs would attest, I have a crazy keen sense of smell. I definitely wouldn’t hesitate getting these again in the future!

These get very soggy and are hard to peel off. Not a fan.

I bought these liners because my local Target was out of my usual parchment paper liners. I mixed up my usual chocolate cupcake recipe and as I was pouring the batter in the individual liners I realized that they were smaller than other liners that I have used. Then the batter began leaking out of the liners and in all of my many years of baking I have never had this happen. I baked my cupcakes as usual but the cupcakes stuck to the liners. Very displeased with these liners and I do not recommend them.

Not standard cupcake sized

just used for first time with muffins. Had to peel off muffin so carefully and lost some of cooked item.

Rip when you pull them off to eat the cupcake or muffin, pulls your baked item apart too, leaks the fats and oils out of the batter making everything dry and a dirty pan. I will not buy these again.

These smell like chemicals. So gross. Will not be using.

Liners stick to muffins and cupcakes. Wouldn’t buy again.

Very pretty but super thin & stick together easily when your trying to take them apart and separate them as you fill them and quite flimsy. Not as good as original other liners that have been around for years. Still despite that they baked up the muffins very nicely and there were no issues there. But unless they improved the quality I doubt I’d buy again.

These liners are completely fine, despite the negative reviews. They are regular sized liners that fit my muffin pans perfectly (one Kitchenaide brand, the other Nordic brand). I think there is some confusion since most muffin pans are extra large sized these days. Additionally, I haven’t experienced any strange smells when using them. Perhaps they fixed that problem? Either way, go ahead and order them. :)

These are very cute, but they are smaller in both diameter and height than normal cups. My cupcakes were smaller than usual because there wasn’t room in the cup and I had a lot of extra batter. They also got very greasy on the bottom outside of the cups after baking. They did the job overall, but I probably wouldn’t buy these again.

These liners are smaller than a normal liner and they stick to the baked item. I used them for muffins and even after the item had cooled completely parts of it stuck to the liner. They are also unusually thin. I normally just buy liners from the grocery store was I was expecting target to be better quality. Would not recommend them at all.