Thayers Natural Remedies Witch Hazel Alcohol Free Toner with Rose Petal

I just picked up a new bottle of my favorite toner (Thayers Rose Petal, alcohol free) and used it for the first time this morning. I could immediately tell that something had changed (face felt dry/tight, rose scent was different), so I dug the old bottle out of the recycling bin and compared the ingredients and confirmed that the formula had changed. Aloe is farther down on the ingredients list and there are more chemicals added. Even the species of rose is different. Why? Why would you change a perfect formula? Did y'all think we would be too stupid to realize that you changed the formula? Even the "frequently ask questions" page lies about the change ("new bottle same formula"). I'm going to try to return this bottle with the new L'Oreal formulation. It's gross. I'll be sure to share this finding with friends and family.

I’ve always loved this product—it made my face feel clean and hydrated. However, I bought a new bottle today and immediately noticed a difference. It felt like it stripped my skin, and there’s also a new scent that I didn’t notice in previous bottles. It seems like they must’ve changed the formula, which is really disappointing. I’m planning to return it and try something else.

I loved all the previous formulation up till this current formulation. No longer work magic on me - no radiant smooth skin. Won't be buying with this new formulation, too many chemicals in it. Don't fix if it is not broken. It is the older formula that makes the brand famous and well known worldwide.

Went to re buy the same one I've been using for a long while. Saw they redid the label (looks more K beauty now versus old timey look, which I didn't mind). But they also changed the ingredients again, lowering the level of Aloe and added new things. Why!!! Stop changing what works really well. The red lid is the same but the plastic of it feels thinner/cheaper. This does not bode well to me. Is the company going cheaper with quality of product as well? I see the witch hazel and aloe in it is no longer organic either. Also the type of rose has changed, from centifolia to damascena. Rosa damascena (Damask rose) and Rosa centifolia (May rose) are both types of roses used in perfumery and skincare. They have different scents and are produced in different regions. The rose in the original formula is produced mostly in France and the new one in mostly Syria and Turkey. I haven't opened my new bottle to see how different it smells as I plan to return it. Companies may not think we see the changes or care, but we do. Time to find a new rose toner.

I broke out terribly while using this! My skin was great prior. I’ll go back to the unscented version. My skin is red, dry, textured, and pimples all over. Never again! My skin is sensitive. Beware..

Like the brand of witch hazel.

Went to re buy the same one I’ve been using for a long while. Saw they redid the label ( looks more K beauty now versus old timey look, which I didn’t mind). But they also changed the ingredients again, lowering the level of Aloe and added new things. Why!!! Stop changing what works really well. The red lid is the same but the plastic of it feels thinner/cheaper. This does not bode well to me. Is the company going cheaper with quality of product as well? I see the witch hazel and aloe in it is no longer organic either. Also the type of rose has changed, from centifolia to damascena. Rosa damascena (Damask rose) and Rosa centifolia (May rose) are both types of roses used in perfumery and skincare. They have different scents and are produced in different regions. The rose in the original formula is produced mostly in France and the new one in mostly Syria and Turkey. I haven’t opened my new bottle to see how different it smells as I plan to return it. Companies may not think we see the changes or care, but we do. Time to find a new rose toner.

I like this brand. I get it when it’s on sale or the price isn’t as high. It does what it’s intended to do, I think. My face seems toned.

I like this product a lot, I would buy it again if I had the opportunity to at my local store.

Just went to but another bottle of what I knew to be a tried and true toner that I used for EVERYTHING only to find out they have added a bunch more ingredients that I usually avoid in my products. This is so unfortunate. I will have to find another brand.

very good product hello . Highly recommended to use it.

in my experience with these kinds of facial products, this one has been great so far on my sensitive skin. doesn't irritate it and leave it too dry. pleasant smell too which isn't overpowering as well

It smells great and has helped even my complexion. It takes some time to dry but I love it!!

I used to use this stuff a few years ago but switched over to normal witch hazel since its cheaper and more pure. I know I didn't develop any sensitivity to witch hazel or rose water because I have rose water wipes. I bought a travel size to put in my carry on for a trip abroad and I'm glad I tested it beforehand because it burned my face bad. Not sure what they added but if you have sensitive skin or an overreactive immune system I would steer clear. A classic bottle of TN Dickinsons is way cheaper for more witch hazel anyways

i ordered it and i wanted it ina bag and they didn’t put it in a bag and now my mom saw her christmas gift.

This is my favorite toner. I think it works, I’m not really sure. But when so apply it, it tingles and I think that’s a good sign. My skin game is giving. On the plus side, it lasts a super long time.

Great product‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️

It's been a while since I've used facial toner from this brand. I use this as part of my daily skincare routine.

I love how it removes all the dead skin or makeup and dirt that still remains after you wash the face. Bought a trial one to see how it works. Definitely a good one!

Ive been using brands half the cost of this for many years and finally gave this a try. Smells really nice and comforting. Soothing and makes my face noticeably less red compared to the other ones I’ve tried. Will be buying this again. Worth splurging for.