Women's Muck Arctic Ice Tall + Vibram Arctic Grip A.T. Boot, ASVTA100, Black

My husband got these for me last Christmas since we spend a lot of time outside with our animals and we live in a colder part of the country. These started splitting last year along the seam, letting in water. This year, they have cracked further, letting in more water. I was very excited about these boots and I am disappointed they haven’t lasted. I thought Muck boots were known for durability.

Not sure why the reviews are negative. These keep me safe in extreme snow conditions. I have been wearing them for 5 years while shoveling/plowing snow and driving in severe conditions. The Vibram snow is excellent for harsh winter conditions.

I purchased my boots in August 2023. Loved them till I didn't. The back of the boots where the ankle and foot bend are cracked and leaking. That's too bad, because finally I found a pair of boots that didn't give me blisters on my heals. Now very disappointed. Way overpriced.

I bought my boots one year ago and they were fantastic until water started leaking in the back of one boot. I was shocked to see that the backs of both boots where the ankle meets the foot bed had cracked from side to side. I've never written a bad review before but felt compelled to warn other folks that these are not reliable. Muck boot needs to go back to the drawing board on this one.

I bought these boots over a year ago and they are amazing! We’re a bit stiff at first but after a few wears the worked in a bit and are better than ever. I wear them fishing in the winter and feel no temperature difference while I’m in the river which is awesome. I’ve worn them in mild fall and spring conditions along with -35 Celsius snowy & icy conditions and I couldn’t wish for a better boot. My husband was so jealous that he ordered the same pair in mens and absolutely loves his too. Highly recommend to anyone! I will be purchasing another pair in the mid height soon as I am so happy!

Bought these to try bc my feet are always cold in every boot. They stay nice and toasty even when I'm ice fishing in these. Comfortable enough to walk in too.

I bought these in Sept 2021. I love these boots. I wore them every day. Comfy and kept my feet warm. BUT, by August the entire sole on each boot was coming off. I re-glued them, but today one ripped completely off. I need to buy another pair now with winter setting in, but I'm going to see if I can find a better option. You would think for as expensive as these are, they would be of better quality and last more than one year!

I wish I never bought these. Shipping took ages to get to me. When they did arrive finally I had high expectations. Just got back from a hunt in 19 degrees and I can't feel my toes. Sat for 3 hours and had to get down from the deer stand because of the pain from the cold in my feet. Extremely disappointed!

within 10 months these boots stat to fall apart. The second pair I was careful to keep clean but that didn't do anything to extend their life beyond a single season. So disappointing. a boot with holes is neither warm no water proof.

My first pair of Muck Boots lasted years... Moving forward I have bought a pair every year for the past three years in a row and only get one winter season out of them (about 4-5 months) before they crack at the heel and are no longer waterproof. They are comfortable boots but our family is moving on to boots that last! Lost our business.

I bought these boots when I was preparing for a contract job in Antarctica. I have worn these boots every single day, out and about at McMurdo Station and in the office for 4 months so far. These boots are toasty, unbelievably comfortable, light, and I have NEVER slipped in these boots. Next year before I head to Antarctica I am going to buy another pair.

I bought these last year before winter came(2021) I love them but the ice grip does not work well. I still slip when shoveling and hiking. also something seems a bit off with the inside stitching. I can feel it in one boot. But I will manage with it, it don’t hurt:) I did have the artic sport that lasted me about 6 years(which I thought was wonderful, best boot ever!) I hope these hold up as well!

I love the fit of these boots and the warmth in the winter, however, after one year the rubber where the toe flexes cracked and split. No longer water and mud proof. Wish they lasted longer.

If you're considering spending money on these boots because of the temperature claims, save your money. They do not live up to their claims. I was told to wear warmer socks by a customer rep. I grew up living through Canadian winters, I wear warm socks!

I bought my Arctic Grip boots a little over a year ago so this Winter is my second season wearing them. Until this Winter they were the warmest, and most comfortable Winter work boots I had ever owned, but this year they began to develop cracks in the toe area and in the back above my ankle. The cracks started small and I tried to fix them as suggested, but they have gotten much bigger and now snow and water are leaking into my boot when I am out. I was hoping this was just a defective pair, but notice several other reviews indicating that their boots have done the same things. These are way too expensive to only be able to use them for one season. I am going to try another model to see if the high volume of wear was just too much for the Arctic Grip, but if this happens again I will have to find a new brand. I can't afford to replace my boots every Winter.

I absolutely loved these boots when I got them just over a year ago! They keep my feet nice and warm, they are super comfortable, and the toe area is nice and wide. My feet can get hot and sweaty with just one pair of socks on - which is fine until I take them off and they stay kind of damp for a couple hours after. That is not so nice. They are hard to get off (even still a year later!) but the tightness keeps the snow out of them. The problem I have is that both boots developed a crack/tear in the crease line of the boot (the part that would kind of wrinkle if you were to go on your toes). The crack is on the side of the boot -not the top. They haven't started leaking and I fixed them with Aquaseal as recommended. I don't think they should wear out like that considering the cost of the boot. I can't afford to buy a new pair of boots every year. I do wear them multiple times each day but I wouldn't call it above normal use.

I liked the Hales so much that I got these for winter. I heard about Arctic Grip being good on ice a couple of years ago so that was a plus but it hasn’t been icy enough to see if this is so. I doubt it as I’ve had boots with Arctic Grip before that didn’t work on certain kinds of ice. I wouldn’t let that be the only reason to chose these. They’re keeping my feet warm in up to -15 Celsius with merino wool socks on. I haven’t tried them with thinner cotton socks. Because of the lining they’re s tighter fit than my Hales of the same size. They’re also much heavier. That was my biggest issue when I first wore them. That and the slightly higher sole made them feel weird the first time I went down the stairs or ran with the dog but they moulded nicely to my feet after a week or so and I can now comfortably run a block in them. They’re easy to put on and a bit harder to take off - I need to hold the heel down with my other foot - but my foot doesn’t slide around in them like it does with the Hales nor do they have as much toe room. I wish they made their boots in half sizes so some of us could get a better fit. As far as their performance goes, I couldn’t be happier. I use them for walking around the neighbourhood which in winter means muddy sidewalks and roads, puddles, ice, sticky snow, deep snow, packed snow, dirty snow and a lot of big sand particles the city users to keep sidewalks safe. The latter get into the spaces of the soles of all my footwear and are a real pain to clean. It’s no different with these. But it’s easy to wash the mud and grime off in the shower so I’m really happy with them, so happy that when I reach for a pair of dressier leather boots to wear I usually grab them instead. I’ve finally found some everyday winter boots that I don’t mind putting on. Time will tell about quality.

Nice light boots that are warm however the "superior ice traction" is poor. They don't provide any extra traction on ice you slip and slide everywhere. If I knew that I would have bought the cheaper arctic version instead of the more expensive Ice.

I live in Manitoba, where it’s commonly -20c and gets down to -45 with the windchill more often than I’d like to admit. I haven’t had these for those extreme temps yet, but dying -15 my feet were TOASTY. I have no doubt these will get me through a kind day of ice fishing etc. I worked outside all day cutting wood in the snow and I had to change into lighter boots because these made me too hot. I’d say these are great for frigid cold, but I wouldn’t get them if I only needed them for -5C.

I actually really this boots, but they're hard to take them off. If you don't mind this then I totally recommended them