Firm Stay Plush Bed Pillow - Threshold

I’ve had this for a while and it has slowly sunken in over time. I would say it provides moderate support at first but doesn’t last if you’re a side sleeper.

Nice big fluffy pillows. I love them!

So comfy! Good support.

Needed firm cuz I'm a side sleeper. Doesn't flatten..have had it 4 nights. Great pillow

This pillow is LOUD. The casing of the pillow itself is like a waterproof, plastic-fabric feel. I tried many different pillow cases in hopes one of them would help it not feel weird and not sound so loud with no luck. It also is not firm as stated. Terrible pillow.

I change sleeping positions quite often throughout the night (side, back, other side) and because of this, I am very selective when it comes to pillows. As I’ve gotten older, I’ve come to realize that “plush”, squishy pillows aren’t appropriate for the best nights sleep. I realized this when I found myself folding pillows for more support or using twice the amount of pillows I previously had. That being said, I’ve also been snobby with pillows… thinking that I “get what I pay for”. These pillows proved me wrong on several accounts. I have been sleeping on them for almost three weeks now and I love them. They are firm and supportive, but have plenty of give so that my head and neck are cradled. The price can’t be beat. The only thing I can’t rate is how long they will last, but at this price point I am willing to replace them yearly if necessary. Well done Target!

Oddly, this pillow sounds crunchy. I had to stop using it after the first night since the sound was so annoying.

Perfect pillows for spare bed

I got this pillow specifically because it says it’s firm but in actuality it’s quite soft and shapeless. I’ve given it three months to give it a chance but it does nothing but cause me discomfort. I recommend looking elsewhere.

I thought this pillow was very high quality and loved the combo of filling materials, but it ended up being just a bit tall and solid for my needs, as I wanted a secondary more squish-able pillow to go on top of my main sleeping pillow. If you're looking for your main, underhead sleeping pillow this might be perfect for you.

I first noticed the difference in the thickness of the pillows after I took them out of the package and placed them on my bed. At first glance I thought one was defective until I noticed the tag. It was obviously a pillow that did not come from Target and had been used. After further examination I noticed both stains and hairs on the pillow. To say that I am disgusted is an understatement!!! I am not even sure how something like this could happen. This is a serious quality control issue, as well as sanitary concern. I am not sure if I will ever purchase anything like this again from Target. If negative five stars was an option, that would still be too many.

Stays firm holds shape

Used the pillow for 2 nights and the seams immediately started to split. Stuffing is pouring out of them and I just purchased them. This is very poor stitching. Shotty work.

It’s hard to say if the pillow would’ve been comfy or not because it was so LOUD! Even when I wasn’t moving, I could hear the pillow

It makes noise and doesn’t provide comfort. Not happy with the pillow.

These are great! Big and plush.

Total waste of money and will wind up in a landfill. Do better Target or don’t bother!

Flat within days - like I may as well not even have a pillow at all. Waste of money.

This updated version is terrible. We have this pillow in the older model. This new one is crunchy like hard plastic, like a waterproof toddler bed cover. It’s very loud. Not soft at all. Even with cotton or silk pillowcases on, it’s still hard and loud. I hate it. Please bring back soft pillows.

Immediate return, caused neck pain for both husband and I.