tarte Maneater Waterproof Mascara - Black - 0.3 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I had been using Tartelette XL, which I loved. But I started having trouble with watery eyes, and it made a goopy mess. I decided to try this since it is waterproof. When my eyes water it doesn’t make as much of a mess as the Tartelette, but some of it still comes off. Aside from that issue, it does a nice job of adding volume and length. I still like Tartelette XL better, but I’ll stick with this until I get my watery eye issues sorted out.

I have been wearing it every since a girlfriend gifted me a couple years ago🤩

A friend gifted me a couple years ago and I have been wearing every since🤩

Works great, wore to a funeral and didn't have black tears

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This waterproof mascara stays on when you want it too but washes off when you are ready.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Wonderful mascara, doesn’t clump and lengthens my eyelashes , and removes very easily

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Might just be me, but irritates my eye. Regular formulation does do this.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Stays on, doesn’t bleed to my under eyes like so many do. Easy to come off with my regular facial cleanser

I take eyedrops everyday so I have to use waterproof mascara if I want to wear makeup. Decided to give this one a go because my regular was out of stock. This is 1000% NOT waterproof. Wore to a funeral and cried and the entire mascara came off and was running down my face and I looked like a raccoon. This is the worst mascara I have ever tried.

Love this product

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really like the mascara makes my lashes look fuller.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This mascara is my favorite out of any out there. The waterproof isn’t as waterproof as others though I’ve tried though.

I bought this mascara because the one I usually buy was out of stock. I figured with it being waterproof it wouldn't smudge but after only wearing it a couple of hours, my under eye is black. I don't have that problem with most mascaras.

It isn't waterproof, smears and washes off with water. Crumbles pretty quick during the day, always had to clean my eyeballs as well. Returning the product.

Maneater covers my lashes revealing their length while separating them! I could not be happier with the results!

It does smear. Not the greatest applicator brush , but I've had worse. Wouldn't purchase again.

I love Tarte products since they are clay based they aren't clumpy and specifically the mascara goes smooth on and feels fine on my lashes.

This mascara does what it says it's going to do!!!

Went on great like the original but flakes and creates horrible raccoon eyes. Very disappointed.

As a gal who has the straightest lashes EVER, waterproof mascara is the only thing that can hold a curl for me. This mascara is in no way waterproof its insane how quickly my eyelashes fell, even with only one or two coats of product. Also, in addition to not being waterproof, I shed a few tears after an AP Calculus exam and it RAN!!! Terrible mascara I don't recommend. Zero stars if possible.