Milani Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner - 0.09 fl oz

I tried this one after my local Target stopped carrying the Milani Stay Put Infinite Eyeliner (gold top) and couldn't be more disappointed. This one stays put where? Not my eyes. It runs and rubs off without much of a fight, which is the polar opposite of the infinite (gold top) version. I think this one shouldn't use the "stay put" name. The infinite (gold top) version is worth the money, this one definitely is not remotely worth the money. Maybe it's the comparison that's killing it for me, but how is this the same company?

I used the regular and I loved It so I got the waterproof thinking it was the same but better it only lasts like 3 hours on my eyes . So Bad !

Love love love this eyeliner. It is my go to eyeliner and it lasts a lot longer than other brands. I would highly recommend this product!

I’ve bought the same eyeliner for years . The quality of this eyeliner has went down so much. It’s like putting water on your eyes. You guys should be ashamed to yourself for ripping people off like you are.

This is my go-to eyeliner when I go to an event. It’s not waterproof, but it does last a long time if you’re not in humid hot weather. I like that it’s really dark and is easy to put on.

I’ve been buying this liner for years now and I love it, truly the only liquid eyeliner I love, I cannot find another that lives up to this one.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This product stays put and doesn't smear! I have been using it for years and refuse to use any other product!

This is definitely not water proof and I’m unable to make a sharp wing with the applicator. The color and finish is pretty but I wouldn’t recommend to anyone who does graphic liner or just wants a point on their wing

Smudges and comes off so easily do not waste your money on this terrible product.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] It’s nice and precise. Iike the brown better than the black and it stays on well

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The applicator of this eyeliner can make a very fine line. I use this to tight line my waterline which is unusually wide. It goes well in between my lashes to blend in the liner. Highly recommend!

I’m an experienced cat eye girl. This eyeliner is very good for the price! Only thing I don’t care for is the applicator hence 4 stars. I would recommend. :)

Used it for several years and will continue to buy!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Love it don't buy any other eyeliner but this one would always. Recommend

This eyeliner is super matte and pigmented. I actually really like the applicator because it doesn’t flex, which makes it easier to draw steady lines. I just wish it was slightly more fine tip to get super precise lines. One major thing that I don’t like is that the eyeliner can crumble off if you try to layer and fix it. However, once it’s dry and you don’t mess with it, it does stay put pretty well.

I always hype Milani products because of the quality, but this liner fell short. This eyeliner is definitely not waterproof nor does it stay on for 17 hours. That's a bold claim but it is for marketing purposes. The liner immediately washed off with water and soap when it's tested on your hand, and that liner will definitely smudge your eyes. The ingredients do not irritate my eyes, like most liners do. The tip needs to be more thinner to create a sharper line.

I like that this is matte and long lasting! I also Have it in black and I love it!!!

This eyeliner lives up to its name. No matter what I do it stays on until I take it off. Perfection!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have used this for years! Never lets me down! Love the matte.

This one does not stay on. A short time after applying the eye liner I got black rainbows on my eye lids. I hate that. You can’t tell when it happens. All of a sudden you are talking to someone and your eye makeup is a mess.