Stila DELUXE Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner- Intense Black - 0.008 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

I typically hate the feeling of eyeliner when applying but this has a super smooth feeling and goes on nicely

I love this eyeliner, and I love the chocolate brown (not TOO light, but not as stark or dramatic as black.) But it ALWAYS starts leaking on me, no matter the circumstance (how I store it, how much I've used it, temperature, etc.) I just can't justify buying it.

Pass on this $14 smaller-than-sample-sized eyeliner.

I had high hopes for this product. The formula itself seems long lasting, waterproof, and intense black. However, the felt tip applicator doesn’t work, so the product is unusable. The tip is so dry that the product won’t brush on. Are they all like this?? Tried it on my hand, a paper towel - nothing comes out. Only when I press hard on the base of the brush does the liquid come out, but it’s no good if I can’t sweep it across my eyelid. Such a waste.

I would have loved it more if the tip was a brush tip, the felt tip was too stiff also would love a matte color. It is too shiny on my eyes and looks bad.

Intense Jade is a great color. I'll definitely buy it again.

Product dried out quickly.

Opened the package and the tip is dry. I tried giving it time to see if it would get better, but nope it’s still dry. I guess I should have read the reviews myself before purchasing. Will not purchase again.

Easy to use! Makes a perfect line. Make it thicker or thinner. Only eyeliner I will use.

This eyeliner wing is gone on me within a few hours of just living and breathing. I wanted to like it. I like thr brown tone and the easy application but sadly it is not long-lasting as advertised.

I have researched eyeliners to death, because my eyes water. I need something that is super-waterproof, and will stay in place. This liner was rated highest on several review sites, so I decided to trust. I used it twice. Both times, the liner was almost completely gone within an hour of application. I returned it.

I love everything about it except that it dries out too fast for the price that you pay for it.

It came 98% dried up. I’ve tried adding some liquid back to it with minimal success. Will not purchase again.

Waste of money would have gave zero Stars if it was gave me an option

I love the colour and I really wanting this to work for me. Unfortunately I have the same experience as others have mentioned, the pen is extremely dry and doesn't apply consistently, and isn't long lasting at all probably because it is so dry. Avoid this product it ended up being a waste of money. :(

You know how when you write with a dry-erase marker, when you go over it again, the second layer erases the first? That's what happens with this eyeliner. Absolutely not buildable. You can't touch it up. If you try, it will make the eyeliner flake off. I wish I could add a video to show you in action. This is one of the worst liquid eyeliners I have ever tried.

I LOVED the black color - used it for years. Great pigment and staying power. BUT the brown is TERRIBLE, which is so sad! It dries out after a couple uses, and the brush gets really flaky. Not sure why the formula is so different from the black. Please fix this!!!

ver watery and runny. I don't have a steady hand so this was a terrible mess for me. Smudged everywhere, so I would not repurchase this again. Back to wet n wild breakup proof liner.

Easy to apply and, amazingly, it lasts all day!

This stuff is so easy to apply, product lasts all day and a long time in general, doesn't dry out and doesn't smudge. I love this for a winged eye liner