ColourPop BFF Mascara - 0.24oz

I was so excited for a red mascara but this was really disappointing. Not even 15 minutes after applying my eyes started to get very red and painful. Not to mention the mascara itself is so clumpy & dry, with little to no actual product getting on your lashes. I love the idea but horrible execution from colourpop :(

Gloopy and dry it was fun to have a colored mascara, but it just wasn’t worth it

As per the other reviews, I received this mascara clumpy, dry, and flaky. Thankfully Target refunded when I opened a chat. The formula flaked and wouldn’t coat my lashes, just sent flakes of red all over my eyelids and under eye. Out of the package it’s dried up and looks like a super old mascara you might find in a drawer, which is not good for a product bought brand new. That said, since Target refunded and told me to keep or toss item, I held onto it. I added a couple drops of water and mixed it in with the spoolie and now it coats my lashes perfectly, is vibrant, and isn’t dry or flaky anymore. So, while I hope Colorpop improves the formula so it isn’t a waste of money out of the package, I found a solution to make the one I was left with actually work. If you still have yours, maybe try a few drops of water. I bought the red color. My review rating is based off initial impression of the product, how it was out of the package before I “fixed” it.

[Pink Inc.; purchased in store] Pros: The pigment is nice and bright. Cons: It's clumpy and dry, it feels like all of the product sticks to the end of the wand. I had to put multiple coats to get any color payoff, even with a white primer. It felt like I was putting hair wax onto my lashes. This is a bummer because I was hoping to mix this into my daily makeup rotation.

The worst mascara I’ve ever used in my life. Attempted to use it once and threw it away. Total waste of money.

This is THE BEST blue mascara I’ve ever bought, and let me tell you, I’ve bought them all! I used to spend a ton on Diorshow, but not anymore! I wore it to work last week and received a TON of compliments!

CLUMPY and not even applicable. Even when you try to apply it, the color barely comes off. I'm talking 10, 20 coats later and still nothing .... Worst mascara i've ever tried.

Don’t buy if your eyes are sensitive. Idk if it’s just this batch or if I’m allergic to something in it but I woke up with red goopy eyes. I washed it off really well before bed too.

Immediately upon looking at the damaged packaging i knew what i would see once i fully opened the tube. Sure enough there was HAIR tangled in the brush. Unsanitary and unsafe. Absolutely disgusting.

awesome color that most brands do not have. Layer it for best look! 🌺 I also find Color pop not to be as allergenic as many 🙌

Fantastic color!

Amazing mascara - so pigmented, thick, and volumous. I love holding the big tube!

My new favorite mascara, no clumping and the perfect color!

Def my new fave mascara. Love the colour and how it goes on. Good sized wand too.

I have the blue & purple. Both are nice colors, but they are a bit clumpy. The blue, you can see nicely on your eyelashes that it's blue. The purple, not quite as much. Not sure I'd it would help if the purple was a little lighter. But in general I'm happy with these mascaras. These are probably some of the best non-traditional color mascaras that I've used.

not sure if i got a faulty batch or what but this mascara crumbled like crazy and i had a HORRIBLE reaction to it… i’m talking red, swollen eyes with yellow/green discharge. not sure if i’m allergic to an ingredient or if the mascara was previously used and it was a bacterial infection but… yeah. super bummed. i really wanted to like the product :(

Perfect when you need red

I LOVE this mascara- it makes my eyelashes look super long and the pigment is fantastic. I wear it with EVERYTHING, the blue adds a pop of color if you're close up but is also subtle enough that far away it looks like regular black mascara

Really shows off lashes!

Great volume and length. I'd like a bluer pigment though, have to apply many layers for the desired blue color.