Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner - 0.016 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

Thought I'd give this liner a chance before making an opinion on it after it applied patchy my first time, but sad to say after many uses it continues to be patchy to apply. The pros of this product were the fine tip and ability to make a sharp wing and the color matching as advertised. The cons list is much bigger. For the price, it is not worth it considering the product is very patchy and you will have areas where there is minimal color and others with dark color. It is hard to go back and apply more on the patchy areas because it dries down very fast and removes color if you try to reapply in those places. The liner does flake off if you rub your eyes. Overall, wouldn't recommend this product for the price point it is at. You're better off with a different brand or even a more affordable brand.

I've been buying these for the last 10 years religiously, but over the last year or so every single one that I have received has either been dried out right out of the box or will last a week or so and then dry out. These used to last me 3-4 months with every day use, but not anymore. It's gotten to the point where i'm sick of returning these again and again - sadly i'm going to have to start looking for a new brand of liquid liner.

This is the easiest and best liquid eyeliner, that I've ever used. It's easy to put on. It doesn't smudge and you can make a fine line so easily. It stays on really well all day! I will not buy any other liquid eyeliner! Its simply the best!

This is the easiest and best liquid eyeliner, that I've ever used. It's easy to put on. It doesn't smudge and you can make a fine line so easily. It stays on really well all day! I will not buy any other liquid eyeliner! Its simply the best!

I read an article boasting the "best liners out there". This was in the list. I was hesitant because of the price but thought, hey, if it really stays all day, it's worth it. Nope. Within 2 hours, I was missing my winged corners already. Had melted down the sides of my eyes. So my search continues for a truly "stay all day waterproof liner".

love almost everything about this eyeliner but it is definitely not waterproof. the lasting power is alright but if my eyes start to water it will fade and i need to reapply

It works for tightlining but if you are doing a wing/ graphic liner then this product is useless. It drags your skin and it patchy.

I typically hate the feeling of eyeliner when applying but this has a super smooth feeling and goes on nicely

I love this eyeliner, and I love the chocolate brown (not TOO light, but not as stark or dramatic as black.) But it ALWAYS starts leaking on me, no matter the circumstance (how I store it, how much I've used it, temperature, etc.) I just can't justify buying it.

Intense Jade is a great color. I'll definitely buy it again.

Product dried out quickly.

Easy to use! Makes a perfect line. Make it thicker or thinner. Only eyeliner I will use.

This eyeliner wing is gone on me within a few hours of just living and breathing. I wanted to like it. I like thr brown tone and the easy application but sadly it is not long-lasting as advertised.

I have researched eyeliners to death, because my eyes water. I need something that is super-waterproof, and will stay in place. This liner was rated highest on several review sites, so I decided to trust. I used it twice. Both times, the liner was almost completely gone within an hour of application. I returned it.

I love everything about it except that it dries out too fast for the price that you pay for it.

I love the colour and I really wanting this to work for me. Unfortunately I have the same experience as others have mentioned, the pen is extremely dry and doesn't apply consistently, and isn't long lasting at all probably because it is so dry. Avoid this product it ended up being a waste of money. :(

You know how when you write with a dry-erase marker, when you go over it again, the second layer erases the first? That's what happens with this eyeliner. Absolutely not buildable. You can't touch it up. If you try, it will make the eyeliner flake off. I wish I could add a video to show you in action. This is one of the worst liquid eyeliners I have ever tried.

I LOVED the black color - used it for years. Great pigment and staying power. BUT the brown is TERRIBLE, which is so sad! It dries out after a couple uses, and the brush gets really flaky. Not sure why the formula is so different from the black. Please fix this!!!

ver watery and runny. I don't have a steady hand so this was a terrible mess for me. Smudged everywhere, so I would not repurchase this again. Back to wet n wild breakup proof liner.

Easy to apply and, amazingly, it lasts all day!